Page 1 of 3

Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 10:43 am
by fermnedoza
Image

Let us keep the official thread for Miss Earth 2019 be about the delegates, the national pageants and all the happenings pertaining to the Miss Earth 2019 pageant. For our suggestions as to the way Carousel Production "ought" or should run the competition, let us use this page (thread) for easy browsing and reference by the "powers that be" within the Miss Earth Organization who visit Missosology from time to time.

Having their own thread will also ensure that our suggestions will be easier to be found instead of being drowned by other information and things that are to be shared by earthlings and earthworms alike.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 10:57 am
by Ea'rend¿l
Yehey! Tita peach, alam mo na. :%))

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 10:58 am
by Ea'rend¿l
My Wishlist and Suggestions...

(1) Please retain the semi-continental format. Top 8 performers based on pre-pageant activities regardless of which continent they belong and then another 8 slots allotted for the girls selected from each continent. Plus 1 for eco-warrior award and another 1 for eco-video. I'm not in favor of the voting.

(2) I agree with Miss Pluto regarding the Welcome Party. Kindly choose a best venue to conduct this. Okada maybe? >:)

(3) Please be sensitive regarding the food being served to the ladies especially if some of them are vegetarian. The same thing goes to sponsors about skin whitening products. Girls must be carefully selected as to who will endorse these products. Bottled water? I'm 50/50 about it. Part of me is saying that ME should stop using bottled water but on the other side, I think it's the safest source of water especially when these ladies are always on the go.

(4) Elemental queens must be present to pass their crowns.

(5) In selection of the winner, I hope part of the judging criteria will be the overall look, not only about the answer. Just like Tereza and Ponkan. :%))

(6) Yes to G-Force as always. Please don't change them.

(7) Opening: Same or at par with 2010, 2011 and 2014 editions.

(8) Announcement of the top performing candidates in each pre-pageant round: I like how it was done last year. For improvement, just flash their names on-screen.

(9) It's okay if the preliminary rounds will not be livestreamed given the signal issue here in PH. Just release an edited video/show of it na lang afterwards.

I'll add some if I can think of any.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 12:45 pm
by hahahahuhu
1. Filipino judges must be limited to only 2 or less.

2. Please get better translators (the Spanish last year was good and almost exact but seems to have difficulty in speaking).

3. Of curse great stage - with lots of lights, even the floors (lol - wishful thinking).

4. Keep the pacing fast, like last year.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 12:46 pm
by mrgary

1) Please keep James Deakin as host without any female co-host. It makes the show nostalgic of beauty pageants past.
2) Kindly flash the country and the name of the semi-finalists on the big screen instead of letting them wear their sashes that almost always fall from their shoulders whenever they strut themselves on stage.
3) No more Karla Henry or Jamie Herrell, please!! Those two girls are so tacky to the core. If push comes to shove that they have to be included in the show, then please do not give them any speaking line so that they don't cheapen the programme.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 12:57 pm
by blunderer
1. Computer Graphics Design on screen for the Finals Night.
2. Get more international judges, specially those who think globally, even for preliminaries.
3. Limit Filipino jdges to 1 or 2, Some Filipino prelim judges have weird choices and sadly not a lot who has a global mindset
5. REMOVE the hashtag round, not all Hashtag trends are the same across all nations
5. Top 20 instead of 18?
6. Make your social media active especially facebook
7. GLAMSHOTS (Venezuela style during Osmel era)
8. I'm sure the semifinalists will all be intelligent, choose someone with a STUNNING FACE like Ponkan.

That's all I can think for now.

PS. Thank you Miss Earth for hearing us the fans.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 1:25 pm
by supladoman
- Better lighting on stage and longer runway.
- Make it a tradition on passing the crowns of all elemental queens. This makes ME unique.
- Glam shots please. We want to see the girls in their beautiful and HD shots.
- Keep the continental format, 1 placement for best in eco video, and 1 for eco warrior awardee
- Make the girls wear simple dress during their opening just like from previous ME years 2015 and below. Maybe they can put their theme costumes on other segments of the pageant like in pre pageants

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 1:49 pm
by ClubEarthMisso
I think its more effective to send your suggestions directly to all Miss Earth social media platforms instead

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 2:46 pm
by quelab22
remove the continental selection... it should be everybody's game... after all, all the candidates gave their best.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 3:52 pm
by Virginia Dalisay
If possible, make the STAGE look fabulous by making it more bigger and wider and by adding more glitters and colorful lights. This is what the whole planet see from start to finish of the pageant night, so might as well make it astoundingly marvelous and splendidly remarkable . >=p >=p >=p >=p >=p >=p <:-P

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 4:08 pm
by blunderer
ClubEarthMisso wrote:I think its more effective to send your suggestions directly to all Miss Earth social media platforms instead


ferm is connected to Carousel

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 5:14 pm
by Power-mad
Chyrons, chyrons, chyrons!
It's hard to believe how something as simple as chyrons can elevate a live TV broadcast and make it look more polished. Heck, the creative team at ABS-CBN can do it for sure it will cost absolutely nothing! If Carousel needs a more recent example, they can refer to the Miss Earth Venezuela-Globovision telecast uploaded on Youtube to see how this (coupled with good TV direction) can result to something almost as good as that coming from the big networks in the US.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 5:19 pm
by manoypoe
Ea'rend¿l wrote:Yehey! Tita peach, alam mo na. :%))


OK PO TITO RAMON, HOPE YOU WILL LISTEN TO US. :-* :-* =D> =D>

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 5:48 pm
by sleuth08
STOP THE PRESS PRESENTATION IN SWIMSUITS. THERE ARE STILL COUNTRIES THAT FROWN UPON WOMEN IN SWIMSUITS. LIKE IN 2016 WHEN IRAQ HAS TO COVER UP AND PALESTINE CANNOT JOIN BECAUSE IT IS AGAINST THEIR RELIGION.

MAYBE DO LIKE BACK IN 2007 WHEN THE DELEGATES WORE COCKTAIL DRESSES WHILE DOING A PRESS CONFERENCE.

I ALSO SUGGEST TO KEEP THE 18-12-8-4 FORMAT AND HOW THE DELEGATES ARE SCORED AS SOON THEY ARE CALLED IN THE SEMIFINALS. THAT'S VERY UNIQUE TO MISS EARTH.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 6:09 pm
by Yna Magenta
1) Translator - after prelim, maghanap na for the top 18, kawawa ang mga na-luz dahil sa chaka o walang translator

2) Top performers (8-10?) for top 18 please, merit-based judging is the real equality, just pick 1 as wildcards from each continent to avoid blackout

3) Tanggalin ang sash during evening/swimsuit competition, nakaka-distract

4) I'm torn with hashtag or photo interpretation nalang?

5) I agree, limit pinoy judges, dapat 80-90% foreigner para wala ng kuda ang mga vakla sa resulta

6) I agree agen, dapat may final look para mahimasmasan ang mga judges sa hype kapag nakasagot ng bongga ang merly, overall package parin dapat ang magwagi

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 7:10 pm
by manoypoe
Yna Magenta wrote:1) Translator - after prelim, maghanap na for the top 18, kawawa ang mga na-luz dahil sa chaka o walang translator

2) Top performers (8-10?) for top 18 please, merit-based judging is the real equality, just pick 1 as wildcards from each continent to avoid blackout

3) Tanggalin ang sash during evening/swimsuit competition, nakaka-distract

4) I'm torn with hashtag or photo interpretation nalang?

5) I agree, limit pinoy judges, dapat 80-90% foreigner para wala ng kuda ang mga vakla sa resulta

6) I agree agen, dapat may final look para mahimasmasan ang mga judges sa hype kapag nakasagot ng bongga ang merly, overall package parin dapat ang magwagi


PHOTO INTERPRETITION I THINK IS MUCH BETTER COZ THE GIRLS HAVE A BETTER CHANCE OF NOT FALTERING IN THE Q AND A PRIOR TO SELECTING THE TOP4.

REGARDING THE JUDGES, IN AUSTRIA, ONLY LORRAINE WAS THE FILIPINO JUDGE, ANGELIA STILL WON AND STILL WE HEARD SOME COMPLAINTS.

FINAL LOOK IS GOOD FOR ME. BUT I REALLY LOVE GREAT SPEAKERS WHICH IS ONLY LACKING WITH QUEEN PONKAN. SHE COULD HAVE BEEN PERFECT IF SHE SPEAKS LIKE KAREN OR KATHERINE.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 8:39 pm
by batobato
Just like last year. Elemental Queens should be present to make their final walk and pass on their crown to their successor

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 8:45 pm
by batobato
Agreed on other Earthlings advice regarding hosting the welcome party at Carousel mansion

It doesn't look good to he honest plus ladies are wearing cocktail dress and gowns they shouldn't be exposed to humid weather of Manila, Okada perhaps?

Change venue for press presentation to a more bigger venue. The one they're holding on their presentation is small and looks dated. And for me I don't like them being presented with their swimsuits on. Cocktail or Filipiaña dress will do

Be sensitive on getting whitening products as sponsor

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 9:14 pm
by JustinSky
here's mine

1. NO TO WHITENING PRODUCT sponsors.
2. No to press presentation wearing swimsuits. Make it more formal.
3. A flower theme photoshoot.
4. Retain the Top 18 selection.
5. Remove the sash in figure and form round and just put graphic design on tv screen.
6. Orient the judges that the Beauty of Face round is based solely on the beauty of the ladies and not the evening gowns. I dont want another Ibasco type of beauty surviving that round in the finals.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Tue Sep 03, 2019 9:47 pm
by Geeyourhair
Carousel will be scratching their heads when they read our suggestions. Each Earthling has its own suggestions and some of which, we are contradicting each other :%)) :%)) :%))

I agree on most suggestions above, but I also disagree on some:

-- I want to keep the hashtag round. It is is very Miss Earth so keep it unless they gonna change it to the "photo" interpretation segment. Enough of the speech and or questions from the judges...other pageants already done that (Miss World, Miss Universe, Miss International). Hashtag solong solo ng Miss Earth.

-- Judges? Gosh be afraid if you select an all foreigner or more foreigner judges. The foreign judges tend to favor more on communication skills...and they do not care much about the beauty. Besides, foreign judges love the Filipina exotic beauty kayo rin baka pagsisihan nyo ang wish na yan.

-- I'm okay with James Deakin as host.

-- Basta pagandahin ang opening number. People will most likely remember the opening number than any other segment of the pageant.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Wed Sep 04, 2019 12:30 am
by Handsama
Some suggestions...

1. Hold a general orientation at the start of the pre-pageant activities. Make clear to the women the chain of command if they have to air any grievances. This way, they don’t resort to social media to air perceived slights. Talk about the rules of conduct. More importantly, tell them not to be afraid to report any untoward behavior towards them by anyone, without fear of any repercussion.

2. A good number of the women are vegans or vegetarians so it’s important that a number of tasty meatless items are provided by their local hosts during travels.

3. I’ve noticed that there were times when the schedule was so hectic that the women were not able to have some downtime to enjoy the famous resorts they stayed at. Let them enjoy the amenities.

4. I know that there are tons of sponsors who want to meet the ladies but it wouldn’t hurt to give them a ‘break’ here and there so they have time to rest and recover between activities. It’s good for the health.

5. Make sure the women are given enough instructions on how to prevent catching any tropical illness that mess up their chances at competing in the finals.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Wed Sep 04, 2019 1:32 am
by Ea'rend¿l
Link of this thread is already sent to admin of ME facebook page.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Wed Sep 04, 2019 2:05 am
by sleuth08
I KNOW THAT THE SUGGESTION IS FOR 2019. BUT I WENT AHEAD AND THOUGHT OF SUGGESTION FOR 2020: DO A 20-15-10-5 FORMAT.

AND ABOUT TIME TO AWARD A FIRST RUNNER UP. IF FOR ANY REASON ELEMENTAL COURT: AIR, WATER AND FIRE COULD NOT FULFILL THEIR DUTY, THE FIRST RUNNER UP WILL TAKE OVER AND BE PART OF THE ELEMENTAL COURT.

BUT WHO KNOWS, THIS CAN BE A SUGGESTION THIS YEAR AS WELL.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Wed Sep 04, 2019 2:19 am
by jsonmcking
Here's mine. please respect my opinion and suggestion.

1. Official Photo shoot for all the candidates with different Theme every year(base on their official theme). Glamshot is the best option if they have enough budget/sponsor for this.

2. Make a proper Pageant Opening just like in 2014, wearing a casual/cocktail dress with video clips in the background screen (video of ladies wearing their costumes). its messy to look at if they will wear their costumes in the opening, plus, some costumes required paint,make up or hair dress that is difficult to pull off in final night.

3. Maintain what is best, and eliminate what is not.
best:
a. Last/final walk of elemental queens (this so Unique, make this a Trademark for Miss Earth)
b. Using of Recycled material for the Stage
c. the criteria ( body, poise, beauty with minimal make up and intelligence round)
d. Of course, the best part of Miss Earth is its Pre Pageant Activities
Worst:
a. Hectic schedules, activities, sponsor visits.
b. Controversy in Judging because of the Filipino Judges.
c. Limited Food option(consider the vegans) unoriented/unmanageable sponsors (story of harassment etc)

3. If Possible, change the design of elemental crowns. those elemental crowns has no harmony, balance and correlation to the design of the main crown

4. Finalist(20): Top 8 for best performance, 9 continental (for the sake of diversity 3 for americas, 3 for Europe, 3 for asia & africa) 1 for eco vid, 1 for social works. 1 MEDALS,

5. Increase the PRIZE of the winner >:) >:) >:)

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Wed Sep 04, 2019 3:43 am
by drake_perez
SASH SASH SASH

Please omit the year from the sash. Since the queen is elected by almost the end of the year, it makes no sense that she'll be wearing a sash all throughout her reign with the year on her sash from the last year.

Change the fucking fabric. That thing looks liken a woven hay.
cut from a rice sack. Have you seen it upclose? And it wears out easily. It doesn't go well with formal gowns in formal events. It looks cheap. Don't let Miss Earth be associated with just indigenous materials. Just like the tacky chair they always use in press presentation, and don't get me started about the craftsmanship of that.

If you really want to use indigenous materials, why not use the ones used in high end barongs? That will look good, won't wear out easily. It's a souvenir of the queen after all.


Image
prometheus film plot

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Wed Sep 04, 2019 5:51 am
by La Tierra
Please further improve the production.

1. Well-lit stage
2. Nicely choreographed swimsuit and evening gown competition. Please use two to three steadicams. Please, please, please.
3. The medal competition is dated and irrelevant. Please spare the girls the hardship of having to go through numerous mock pageants when they’re immaterial to the Top 16 rankings.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Wed Sep 04, 2019 8:04 am
by blunderer
La Tierra wrote:Please further improve the production.

1. Well-lit stage
2. Nicely choreographed swimsuit and evening gown competition. Please use two to three steadicams. Please, please, please.
3. The medal competition is dated and irrelevant. Please spare the girls the hardship of having to go through numerous mock pageants when they’re immaterial to the Top 16 rankings.


If they will insist on the medals, I suggest that they make it count for the top 18. Maybe perhaps 3-5% comes from it?

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Wed Sep 04, 2019 8:32 am
by manoypoe
Please dont ever scrap the mini competitions and awarding of medals. They serve so many purpose. It gives the queens some bragging rights. When they come home, they have something to show to their countrymen.

The mini competitions also serve as their way of entertaining the crowd of their visited towns or cities. The audience is happy and the girls are rewarded. The girls I think now know that these medals have no bearing in the overall standing. Only 3 prelims are scored but the mini competitons will also test the characters of the girls.

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Wed Sep 04, 2019 9:16 am
by mulholland
remove those wrapper thing of the bouquet of flowers handed to the winners and yes those sashes during evening gown and swimsuit rounds are so distracting

Re: Miss Earth 2019: Suggestion Thread

PostPosted: Wed Sep 04, 2019 9:26 am
by Ligaya Magdalena
Virginia Dalisay wrote:If possible, make the STAGE look fabulous by making it more bigger and wider and by adding more glitters and colorful lights. This is what the whole planet see from start to finish of the pageant night, so might as well make it astoundingly marvelous and splendidly remarkable . >=p >=p >=p >=p >=p >=p <:-P

BOKLOOOHH, ALAM MO NAMANG POORISIMA DE LEON ANG MISS EARTH KAYA PURO TIPID ANG PEG. TULOY NAPAG IWANAN NA SILA NG MISS GRAND INTERNATIONAL PAGEANT NI NAWAT KUNG PA-BONGAHAN LANG SA STAGE ANG PAG UUSAPAN. KUNG KULANG SA BUDGET EH DI MAG SOLICIT SA MGA MAYAYAMAN DIYAN SA PILIPINAS. KAY CHAVIT, SA MGA MARCOSES, KAY SY, KAY LUCIO TAN. KAY VILLAR, SA MGA AYALA. MAKE A WAY, HINDI LALAPIT SA INYO ANG PERA KUNG WALANG KAYONG GAGAWIN. [-( [-( [-( [-( [-( [-( [-( [-( [-( [-(